"I Didn't Choose Immigration Law. It chose me" - How Attorney Alexis Beshears Found Her Calling in Defending the Most Vulnerable
"I Didn't Choose Immigration Law. It chose me" - How Attorney Alexis Beshears Found Her Calling in Defending the Most Vulnerable

A group of friends rushed through the doors of a small law office in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, fear written across their faces. Their friend had been detained. His immigration case had already been dismissed, the appeal window had closed, and no one could tell them what to do next.

Alexis Beshears listened. Then she took the case.

What followed was a scramble against the clock, a weekend spent rebuilding a file riddled with errors, sleepless nights, and a hearing that almost no one believed could end well. Her boss, she recalls, gave the case a ".0001 chance" of succeeding.

But Beshears fought anyway. And she won.

That case, which ended with a detained man winning asylum and an eventual path to reuniting with his family, has become a defining story for the young attorney. It captures the essence of why she practices immigration law, a field she never planned to enter but now cannot imagine leaving.

From Detective Dreams to Courtroom Reality: Alexis Beshears' Path to Immigration Law

Beshears did not set out to become a lawyer. When she enrolled at East Carolina University in Greenville, North Carolina, she had her sights set on becoming a detective, perhaps working in crime scene investigation. She studied criminal justice and went on a ride-along with a local police officer to see the work up close.

It did not take long for her to recalibrate. "I asked him a ton of questions," she says, "and decided, I don't know if I want to be a police detective. Just didn't seem like a good fit."

What followed was a period of genuine self-reflection. Beshears remembered a childhood fascination with the idea of being an attorney. She interned at a criminal defense firm in Greenville for six months, found the work deeply engaging, and committed to the path. She enrolled at North Carolina Central University School of Law with every intention of becoming a criminal defense attorney.

Law school reinforced that plan. She worked in the criminal defense clinic, interned for a North Carolina appellate judge, and even did a brief immigration internship that, at the time, did not especially excite her. She took the bar exam, did not pass the first time, and then passed on her second attempt. A few months later, a former classmate called with an unexpected offer: a position at his immigration firm.

"I said, sure, let's try it out," she recalls, laughing. "Because I wasn’t drawn to that area of law during the internship I did in law school. So I was like, yeah, let's do it."

How Immigration Law Aligns With Criminal Defense: An Attorney's Unexpected Calling

Within six months, something clicked. The work, she realized, was built on the very same motivations that had drawn her to criminal defense: the desire to stand beside people in the most difficult chapters of their lives.

"The whole purpose of me wanting to practice criminal defense was because I wanted to help people in one of the toughest times of their lives," she says. "That aligns with immigration as well. Helping people in very rough times, being in court. I always say that I didn't choose immigration. It kind of chose me. And I am thankful that it all worked out that way."

Today, Beshears is an associate attorney at the Law Office of Amro Elsayed in Winston-Salem, a small but mighty firm that punches well above its weight. It is just two attorneys, supported by paralegals and translators, handling a caseload that spans continents. Their clients come from West Africa, Egypt, Jordan, Central America, Haiti, Indonesia, Togo, and beyond.

Asylum, VAWA, and U Visas: Inside Alexis Beshears' Humanitarian Immigration Practice

Beshears' practice centers on humanitarian-based cases. She handles asylum claims for people fleeing persecution, Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) cases for victims of abuse, and U visa petitions for crime victims who cooperate with law enforcement. Much of her work unfolds in immigration court, defending clients in removal proceedings.

The cases are demanding and deeply personal. She is not processing paperwork; she is fighting to keep families together, to protect people from being sent back to the very dangers they fled.

Immigration Law in 2025-2026: How Attorneys Are Adapting to a Changing Legal Landscape

The legal climate has shifted dramatically since Beshears began practicing. When she started in December 2024, the transition between administrations had not yet reshaped day-to-day casework. By March 2025, that changed. New regulations arrived at a dizzying pace, and the predictability that attorneys once relied on in immigration court and at USCIS evaporated.

"We've had to spend probably twice the amount of time we would usually spend on a case to ensure that we have covered all the bases," she explains. "Where we would think that one case was a solid win, we know that overwhelming evidence isn't always enough evidence."

The firm has responded by becoming more meticulous, more specific in their legal arguments, and more vigilant about detail. Cases that once felt straightforward now require layers of additional evidence and preparation. "These cases are a little bit more vulnerable than they were a year ago," she says.

Beshears is also candid about what she sees as a broader enforcement-first posture that, in her view, harms both immigrants and the communities they belong to. She describes reaching out to Immigration and Customs Enforcement to ask why a client was detained and receiving no response. "There probably isn't a reason why they were detained," she says. She points to the economic cost of detaining individuals who were working, paying taxes, and supporting families. She sees the current approach as a fear tactic designed to exhaust people into giving up on their cases.

Against All Odds: The Asylum Case That Defines Alexis Beshears' Immigration Career

Of all the cases Beshears has handled, one stands apart.

The client was not hers when his friends appeared at the firm's door. He had been detained. His previous case had been dismissed, and the appeal period had already expired. By every standard measure, the situation looked hopeless.

Beshears and her colleague decided to take on the case anyway. By what she describes as an act of grace, the man's case was reopened. But the timeline was brutal: the judge set the final hearing just two weeks out, and when Beshears reviewed the client's application, she found it was filled with errors.

"I'm freaking out," she recalls. "His case was truly a mess. If you asked my boss, he would tell you he thought there was a .0001 chance of him winning." She spent the weekend rebuilding the file, gathering evidence, and preparing a client who could not read or write.

Then came the hearing. The client performed well. The government attorney, perhaps recognizing the extraordinary circumstances, did not press aggressively. The judge granted asylum.

But the relief did not end there. When Beshears tried to secure his release from detention, ICE initially refused, saying they would hold him pending a possible appeal. Then, a week later, the call came: he was being released.

"He came to the office as soon as he was released," she says, her voice brightening. "He was so happy. I was so happy. It was one of those situations where the underdog won and it was very heartwarming. He still comes to the office like every two weeks to tell me hey, and thank you."

There is a postscript to this story that makes it even more meaningful. Because the man won asylum, his family members will eventually be able to immigrate to the United States and join him. One case, one hard-fought win, and an entire family's trajectory changed.

How Immigration Attorneys Are Using AI: Alexis Beshears on Technology in Legal Practice

Despite working at a small firm, Beshears has embraced artificial intelligence as a daily tool. Her applications range from the practical to the strategic.

On the practical end, she uses AI to refine her professional communications, running draft emails through AI tools to ensure clarity and tone. She relies on it for proofreading legal briefs, particularly after long hours of drafting when her own eyes might miss errors. "It's definitely helpful in that sense," she says. "I don't have to have three people in the office proofread for me."

Her more creative applications are what set her apart. She consults AI to anticipate how ICE officers might perceive a message and to rephrase communications for maximum effectiveness. She uses it to prepare clients for hearings by simulating the kinds of questions the Department of Homeland Security might ask. And she uses it to stress-test her own cases, asking AI to identify weaknesses she might have overlooked.

"It doesn't catch everything," she acknowledges, "but it brings up points that I didn't even think of. So it's a very useful tool and it helps save me a lot of time on certain things for sure."

Advice for Aspiring Immigration Attorneys: Networking, Internships, and Finding Your Fit

For aspiring lawyers still searching for their niche, Beshears has strong, practical advice. She is a firm believer in networking, specifically the kind that goes beyond panel discussions and LinkedIn connections. She advocates for one-on-one conversations with working attorneys, the kind where candor is possible.

"I noticed attorneys, when they do social media or a YouTube video, they're kind of censored in a way," she says. "A real one-on-one conversation is where you can get a real feel for how it's actually going to be."

She encourages law students and undergraduates to pursue internships aggressively, noting that many attorneys are eager to teach and mentor. "I don't think it's very difficult to get an internship at a law office," she says. "We're always looking for interns." The key, she argues, is to try different environments: big firms, small practices, different areas of law.

She also shares a candid reality that she wishes someone had told her sooner: practicing law is harder than law school. "I know a lot of attorneys, when I talk to them, they discuss that the actual legal career was more difficult than law school. And that kind of scared me. But it's true," she says. "I thought law school was gonna be the hardest part."

Her favorite question to ask attorneys in those one-on-one conversations: "What is something that you learned that you wish you would have known five years ago?"

What Immigration Attorneys Tell Their Clients: Safety, Rights, and Resilience

Beshears' counsel to her own clients reflects both legal rigor and genuine compassion. She advises them to stay safe, to avoid situations that could lead to detention, and to proactively gather evidence for their cases so that, if they are detained, their legal files are already assembled.

She teaches them their rights: that a pending asylum application provides a legal basis to remain in the country, that they should not sign anything presented by ICE officers without understanding what it says, and that they should always ask for their attorney.

But perhaps her most important advice is the simplest: keep fighting. "A lot of my clients have a very cynical view of the immigration system," she says. "They feel like, no matter what they do, they're still gonna get an order of removal or get deported. And in some cases, honestly, that has been happening."

Even so, she tells them to build the record. Even when a case is lost today, a well-documented file can be the foundation for an appeal or a motion to reopen in the future. "I do have faith in things getting better soon," she says.

The Future of Alexis Beshears' Immigration Practice: Federal Court and Expanding Access

Beshears' goals for the next few years are ambitious but grounded. She wants to open offices for the firm in different states, leveraging the fact that immigration law is a federal practice, meaning her South Carolina license allows her to represent clients before immigration courts anywhere in the country.

She is particularly drawn to federal litigation: suing USCIS when the agency makes errors, and pursuing habeas corpus petitions to secure the release of people from detention centers. "Habeas is a very important thing in immigration right now," she says, noting the growing number of individuals being held in detention without clear justification.

For a young attorney still early in her career, the vision is clear. She wants to be in the courtroom, fighting on behalf of people who have few other advocates. And she wants the system, however imperfect, to work.

LegalBridge Magazine spotlights the leaders, innovators, and advocates shaping the future of immigration and global mobility. Through in-depth conversations, we share the stories and insights of attorneys, corporate mobility professionals, and policy experts who are making a difference.

Join Our Newsletter

Stay Updated with Our Latest News

Get started

Subscribe

Get started

Transform your legal practice today.