The warning came in 1999, and Dan Gividen never forgot it.
He was a high school senior who had been kicked out of his home, 18 years old and homeless, facing what he now calls "a dumb felony charge" for trying to pass a check. His lawyer laid out the options. He could serve six months in jail, or he could plead to a felony and she would argue for probation. Then she told him something that stung more than either choice. With a felony, he would never walk up the courthouse steps as an attorney.
Becoming a lawyer was the one thing he had always wanted. "Which is ironic," he says, "because I hated school."
This past summer, more than a quarter century later, Gividen walked down the steps of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit in New Orleans after oral arguments. The Gulf heat soaked him through in the 90 seconds it took his ride to arrive.
Today he is the founder of Gividen Law, PLLC, a federal court practice in Allen, Texas, in the Dallas-Fort Worth area. The firm focuses on ICE habeas petitions, denaturalization defense and the collision of criminal and immigration law that practitioners call crimmigration. Between that warning and those courthouse steps runs one of the more unusual careers in American immigration law: a former ICE Deputy Chief Counsel who says he spent most of his government career fighting for the people on the other side of the courtroom.
A Felony Charge at 18 and Dan Gividen's Road to Law School
Gividen tells his story the way he practices law: directly, without polish and with a fair amount of humor. "Anything I give is the short version," he warns, "but it's not going to seem like it because I'm long winded."
After that charge, he says, he had to work relentlessly to prove himself. He went on to law school with a single goal: to become a public defender. Working for the government was not part of the plan. Had anyone predicted it, he says, he would have assumed he had lost his mind.
How Judge Jorge Solis Changed the Course of Dan Gividen's Career
The turning point was a clerkship with Judge Jorge A. Solis of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. Gividen was the first clerk the judge hired for his year, and Judge Solis knew about the mistakes Gividen had made at 18. Gividen does not hedge when he describes him. "He was without question the greatest man I've ever known. Most important person in my life."
When Gividen and his wife finished law school, the 2008 financial crisis had hollowed out the legal job market and firms were letting people go. Judge Solis offered advice that Gividen first found absurd. If he truly wanted a say in who gets prosecuted and who ends up in immigration proceedings, the judge suggested, he should consider the government side.
"I looked at him like he was crazy," Gividen recalls. The judge also pointed out that his attitude toward the government "probably wasn't going to serve me well as a young attorney, and I might need to make some friends on that other side."
The suggestion carried an irony Gividen still laughs about. During his internship in the judge's chambers, one of the clerks had accepted a job with ICE, and his younger self had confronted her. "How could you work for this? What is wrong with you?"
Still, ICE was hiring, and two former Solis clerks already worked in its Dallas-area office. Gividen applied, interviewed and received an offer. Around the same time, a large Texas law firm made him an offer, then withdrew it after learning about his background. "Judge Solis was not impressed with that," he says.
The government's background check took a long time. While he waited, Gividen worked at a criminal defense firm handling court-appointed cases, close to the public defender work he had always wanted. When the check finally cleared, the FBI agent who had interviewed him confessed he expected the file to be a waste of time. Then he read it. Gividen had listed everything, including the kind of minor job mishaps most applicants never mention. The agent called him "the most honest person I've ever seen." Gividen went on to hold a secret clearance with DHS for years.
Even then, he did not want to go. "The idea of going to the government side made me sick. It did. I'm not even gonna pretend."
Over lunch, Judge Solis made his case one more time. Go work for the government, he told Gividen, pass the background checks and earn the clearance, "and you're not going to have to worry about this in the future." The judge understood it was a way to put the past behind him for good.
Gividen agreed, on one condition. "All right, Judge," he told him, "but I'm blaming you if it doesn't work out."
Inside ICE: Fighting for Respondents From the Government's Side
He joined ICE's Office of Chief Counsel in Dallas in 2011 as an Assistant Chief Counsel. By the account of his mother and his wife, he was livid about two weeks in, frustrated by what he was watching in the courtroom. Then he did exactly what Judge Solis had said he could do. He made sure he was the one making the decisions on that side.
"I spent most of my career with ICE fighting for the respondents," he says.
His signature project began with a Fifth Circuit precedent known as Renteria, which held that a conviction could still count for immigration purposes even after it was vacated. Gividen watched people ordered removed based on convictions that criminal courts had already set aside because the defendants never received effective assistance of counsel. Most of the immigration bar considered the rule indefensible, he says, and the dissent in the case had said as much.
So he built a litigation strategy to change it. It took several years. In 2018, about seven years after he started, the Board of Immigration Appeals issued a published decision on the issue. That same year, the Dallas Bar Association's Immigration Law Section gave him its Immigration Professionalism Award, in part because of that decision.
It was not an isolated effort. During the Obama administration, he pushed for the ability to dismiss proceedings against people who merited it. From 2014 to 2016, he was detailed to the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Northern District of Texas as a Special Assistant U.S. Attorney, and as a federal prosecutor he tried a major H-1B visa fraud case. Throughout, he held to the standard Judge Solis had set: "making sure that the people that deserved the second chance... got it. Making sure that we didn't indict people just for the stats."
He nearly left immigration work for good. Near the end of his detail, he interviewed with the Federal Public Defender's office, the job he had wanted since law school. The interview went well. A week and a half later, the federal defender called him personally to say the office had hired someone else because it badly needed Spanish speakers. Instead of leaving ICE then, Gividen was promoted to Deputy Chief Counsel in May 2016. He was also teaching immigration law at UNT Dallas College of Law, and he gave his students a clear rule for his own career. He would stay in government "as long as I think I'm doing more good on that side than I could be doing elsewhere."
Founding Gividen Law, PLLC in Dallas-Fort Worth
By late 2018, that equation had shifted. The job had become, as he puts it, "fighting with ICE officers” about their need to comply with “the Fourth Amendment.”
The exit came with unusual timing. His oldest son was born on December 12, 2018, which is also Gividen's birthday. About two weeks later the federal government shut down, and he was furloughed during what was meant to be paternity leave. Around then, a private immigration attorney offered him an empty office, rent free, to get a practice off the ground. She had once been given a free office herself when she started out, and she told him to pay it forward. She was also the attorney whose name appeared alongside his on the joint appeal in that BIA case.
His wife, an employment-based immigration lawyer he calls "much smarter" than himself, had one condition: someone else would handle the finances and keep the books. The business side of having a practice is something that makes Gividen’s eyes glaze over with boredom. This is why "nobody trusts me to be in charge of finances," he admits.
Gividen left ICE in May 2019 and opened Gividen Law. "The dream had always been to have my own practice, do what I want to do, and take the cases that I want to take."
For the first two years, nearly every referral came from other immigration attorneys. He quickly became the lawyer people called when nobody else knew what to do. The relationships he had built inside ICE held up because they were real. "I'm not good at schmoozing. I'm not good at being a fake person," he says. Practitioners knew he had genuinely been on their side, and the welcome when he crossed over was warm.
Early on, court-appointed federal criminal defense work helped sustain the firm while he built a docket of removal defense, BIA appeals and USCIS cases. Crimmigration became his niche: advising on the immigration consequences of guilty pleas, and counseling clients contacted by Homeland Security Investigations or USCIS's Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate. He credits Daisi Quintana as "the lifeblood of this practice," a lesson the firm learned when her maternity leave became "the worst 12 weeks of my entire private practice career."
Why Gividen Law Turned to ICE Habeas Petitions in Federal Court
In mid-2025, the practice changed direction. At the turn of June into July that year, Gividen began filing habeas petitions in federal court, drawing on experience few immigration attorneys share: a federal clerkship, years as a prosecutor and a track record in Administrative Procedure Act litigation.
The first wave included Vietnamese nationals who had arrived before 1995 and could not be removed. For roughly 25 years, they had dutifully appeared for annual check-ins. Now ICE was detaining them when they showed up. Most were not fighting a flight to Vietnam, Gividen notes. They simply did not want to spend four or five months in detention after reporting faithfully for a quarter century. "They just showed up to your office, dude," he says.
At the same time, his faith in the administrative immigration courts was eroding. Speaking candidly about something he says few immigration attorneys like to acknowledge, he believes immigration judges who were simply reasonable, even those who often leaned the government's way, lost their jobs. "I don't know anybody who's even pretending like the IJs are neutral right now or the BIA is neutral," he says. "It just starts taking a toll on you."
The firm's own ethic sharpened that toll. Gividen Law tells people when it does not believe they can win. "We don't take their money," he says. "We explain to them exactly why." As success came to mean hoping "to be that one in a thousand that's getting granted these days," honest consultations meant delivering hard news more and more often.
So the firm stopped taking immigration court cases and committed fully to federal court. "We're just drawing a straight line now," he says. Many clients now arrive through other immigration attorneys, who hire Gividen Law for the habeas petition while they continue the removal case. In the year before our conversation, the firm filed close to 200 habeas petitions.
Denaturalization Defense: The Next Front for Naturalized Citizens
As federal appeals courts weighed in on the bond eligibility question at the center of the BIA's Matter of Yajure Hurtado decision, the volume of habeas work began to ease. That shift coincided with a new threat. The Justice Department's Office of Immigration Litigation began sending letters to people who naturalized in the 1990s, warning that complaints would be filed in U.S. district court to revoke their citizenship.
Gividen Law has already been retained by nine or ten people for denaturalization defense, in states including Indiana, California and Texas. The evidence in these cases, he notes, is the same paper trail that runs through every immigration file: the client's A-file, prior asylum applications and any records of other identities. It is immigration law argued in federal court, the intersection where Gividen has spent most of his career.
Dan Gividen's Advice for Immigrants Navigating Today's System
Asked for his top advice, Gividen reflects on how much the answer has changed. "I would love to have been asked that question two years ago," he says. Today nearly all of it centers on one goal: staying off the radar of ICE and USCIS while getting honest, complete legal advice.
1. Think twice before an ICE check-in if you have no removal order
His first piece of advice is pointed. For people who do not have a removal order but are scheduled to check in with ICE, he advises against going. Missing a check-in is not a crime, he explains, although it does give ICE a legitimate basis to detain someone for violating release conditions. His reasoning is that many people are being detained at check-ins anyway, so "make them work for it." Right now, he says, ICE is shooting fish in a barrel. "Quit jumping in the barrel."
2. Get full advice on every option and its consequences
Some filings now carry risks they did not carry before. Gividen Law no longer takes cases where a client can file an I-130 but is not eligible to adjust status with an I-485, leaving the long I-130 and I-601A provisional waiver route. His concern is the interview itself. His understanding is that people who are not adjustment eligible are often being picked up by ICE when they appear. For many, his honest advice is to wait. "Call us on January 21st of 2029," he tells some of them.
He acknowledges this advice is bad for business, his own included. He believes clients deserve the full picture before they act.
3. Choose an attorney who cares about you, not just the fee
His third piece of advice is to find "an immigration attorney who truly cares about their clients, not just their bottom line." He sees plenty of them. In his view, the private immigration bar has stepped up and reached "the level of feistiness" he used to urge from the other side of the courtroom, with many attorneys taking real time to explain these risks.
4. Let a stalled application stay stalled
People often come to him worried that a petition has been pending too long. His response surprises them. "If they forgot about your application, good," he says. In the current climate, he warns, the likeliest result of being remembered is a denial letter and a notice placing you in removal proceedings.
5. Stay informed without carrying it all home
His last piece of advice comes from experience. He describes a client in her second trimester of pregnancy who had lived in the United States for 13 years. She was still in removal proceedings, with no removal order. One morning she dropped off her eight-year-old U.S. citizen son at school, promising to see him when school let out. Then she went to her ICE check-in. She did not come home that afternoon.
Stories like hers weigh on families and on the lawyers who carry their cases, including his own team. His advice to everyone, whether a parent with a child in custody or an attorney fielding desperate calls, is to stay current on what is happening while finding a healthy way to cope with the emotional weight. "It really is hard, man," he admits.
Back to the Courthouse Steps
When we spoke, Gividen was preparing to fly to Washington, D.C., to be sworn in before the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, one of the few federal courts that requires attorneys to attend its admission ceremony in person. A FOIA case of his had been transferred there. His oldest son, now seven, was coming along and looking forward to the trip.
It is a fitting image. The 18-year-old who was told he would never walk up the courthouse steps as an attorney now climbs them for a living, in Texas, in New Orleans and in Washington, and this time with his son along for the journey.
His career has turned on second chances: the one Judge Solis helped him earn, the ones he fought for inside the government, and the ones he now pursues for clients in federal court. Judge Solis once told him he could make sure the people who deserved a second chance got one. Nearly two decades later, Gividen is still doing exactly that, just from a different side of the courtroom.











